Multi-generational family enjoying a picnic with their dog

Put Your Legacy on Cruise Control Learn More About Us

Probate Litigation Attorney in Florida

Planning-Rooted Perspective. Steady Guidance for Contested Florida Estates.

At Dorcey Law Firm, PLC, we work with individuals and families navigating probate disputes across Florida. These situations can become complicated quickly, and we provide clear, steady guidance from the first conversation forward. We’ve served thousands of clients across estate planning, asset protection, and elder law, and we bring that same depth of knowledge to contested matters. Our attorneys hold recognition including Super Lawyers and Florida Trend, are peer-rated for ethical standards and legal ability, and the firm is a member of WealthCounsel. Free initial consultations are available for families facing probate disputes.

Probate litigation arises when disputes over a deceased person’s estate can’t be resolved outside of court. These disputes can involve will contests, trust administration conflicts, fiduciary misconduct, and beneficiary disagreements. Florida’s probate process is governed by the Florida Probate Code, which sets specific rights and obligations for heirs, beneficiaries, creditors, and personal representatives. Getting these matters right requires both a firm command of Florida law and an understanding of the family circumstances underneath the legal issues.

If you’re facing a probate dispute in Florida, call us at (239) 309-2870 to schedule your free initial consultation.

Probate Litigation Services We Handle

Probate litigation often involves disputes among heirs, beneficiaries, and executors. We handle a range of contested matter types, including:

Will Contests: Challenging or defending the validity of a will.
Trust Disputes: Addressing issues related to trust administration and fiduciary duties.
Estate Administration: Guiding executors in fulfilling their responsibilities.
Guardianship Litigation: Managing legal matters related to guardianship roles.

In many Florida estates, these disputes are intertwined with questions about homestead property, elective share claims, or creditor issues that can significantly affect how and when assets are distributed. We evaluate the full picture of the estate, including non-probate assets, business interests, and existing planning documents, so that any litigation strategy accounts for both immediate court issues and long-term family and tax consequences. When appropriate, we work with financial professionals to help you understand the economic impact of different options before you commit to a course of action.

Florida Statute 732.502 sets the execution requirements a will must meet to be valid. Failure to meet those requirements is one recognized ground for a will contest, alongside lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, and duress. Trustees in Florida carry fiduciary duties including loyalty, impartiality, prudent investment, and avoiding conflicts of interest. A breach of those duties can support removal or surcharge actions. Florida’s elective share statute gives a surviving spouse the right to claim 30% of the elective estate, absent a valid premarital or postnuptial agreement, making elective share claims a frequent source of litigation in Florida probate courts.

Why Clients Choose Dorcey Law Firm, PLC for Probate Litigation

We bring a perspective to contested matters grounded in our estate planning work. Because we actively maintain estate plans and fund trusts for Florida families, our litigation team already understands how the underlying documents were built and where implementation may have broken down before a dispute ever reaches court. That background can shorten the investigative phase and gives clients a clearer picture of what happened and what can realistically be done.

Full-Time Trust Funding Department: Our dedicated Trust Funding Department works on hundreds of trust-related matters annually. That direct familiarity with how estates are funded and assets are titled becomes a meaningful advantage when disputes arise over those same details.
Auto-Pilot Planning Program: Our structured plan maintenance program documents ongoing updates to client estate plans. For litigation matters, this history provides insight into the intent behind documents when recent changes are called into question.
Planning-Rooted Case Insight: Long-term client relationships mean we sometimes have context about a family’s planning history that outside firms would need months to reconstruct.
Multi-Attorney Team: Defined roles across our attorneys give clients access to a broader base of legal knowledge across both estate planning and contested matters.
Structured Communication: Priority scheduling options and defined response timelines mean you won’t be left waiting and wondering about the status of your case.

Our Probate Litigation Process in Florida

We guide you through each step of the probate litigation process in Florida with transparent, efficient service:

Initial Consultation: Discuss your concerns and learn about our approach.
Case Evaluation: Assess the specifics of your case, identify challenges, and outline strategies.
Filing and Documentation: Complete all necessary legal filings and submit important documents to the relevant Florida courts.
Mediation and Negotiation: Work toward fair and favorable resolutions before litigation escalates.
Representation in Court: When necessary, we advocate for your interests before the court.

As your case moves forward, we help you gather and organize the records that often become central in a dispute: prior wills, trust amendments, medical records, and communications with the deceased. We explain how judges in Florida probate courts typically evaluate evidence in will contests, fiduciary removal actions, and accounting disputes so you understand why certain documents and witnesses matter. Throughout, we discuss the range of possible outcomes and how different choices may affect the length and cost of the case, so you can make informed decisions at each stage.

Florida probate courts have specific documentation requirements, filing deadlines, and procedural rules that must be followed precisely to avoid delays or loss of rights. Mediation is frequently ordered or pursued in Florida probate disputes and can resolve conflicts more efficiently than a full trial while preserving family relationships. We pay close attention to these procedural requirements from day one so that nothing procedural interferes with moving your matter forward.

Common Types of Probate Disputes in Florida

Families in Florida encounter a range of issues that can lead to probate disputes. Some arise quickly after a loved one’s passing. Others surface months or even years later as new information comes to light. Recognizing the patterns that often lead to litigation helps you protect your rights and respond strategically rather than react under pressure.

Will Validity and Fiduciary Conduct

Disputes frequently center on will validity: claims that a will was signed when the person lacked testamentary capacity, was subject to undue influence, or didn’t meet Florida’s signing and witnessing requirements. Other conflicts involve how a personal representative or trustee is managing assets, whether they’re providing proper accountings, or whether they’re favoring certain beneficiaries over others. In some estates, family members disagree about how to interpret unclear provisions, how to handle closely held businesses, or whether homestead property and jointly owned accounts have been treated correctly under Florida law.

Statutory Rights and Distribution Conflicts

There are also situations where a beneficiary or surviving spouse believes they’ve been improperly excluded from an inheritance or that statutory rights, such as elective share or family allowance rights, have been overlooked. These cases often involve detailed review of financial records and the history of the family relationships involved. Our role is to help you understand which issues are most important to raise in court, what remedies may be available, and how any action you take might affect the timing of distributions and long-term family dynamics.

Florida Probate Courts and Local Considerations

Probate disputes in Florida are handled in the probate division of the circuit courts, and each county may have its own preferences for filings, hearings, and scheduling. Lee County matters, for example, move through the probate division of the Circuit Court at the Lee County Justice Center in Fort Myers, and its rules may differ from those in other counties. The 20th Judicial Circuit uses a structured, checklist-driven filing process, and filings must be fully posted to the court’s electronic system before proposed orders will be reviewed. Understanding these local practices can affect how quickly your case moves and how documents need to be prepared to be accepted without delay.

Local considerations can also influence where a case should be filed and whether related issues, such as guardianship matters or related civil claims, should proceed in the same court or in a separate action. Venue questions arise when a decedent owned property in more than one Florida county or maintained ties to another state, requiring a threshold determination before the matter proceeds. We address these questions at the outset so that time and resources aren’t lost litigating in the wrong place.

Under Florida Statute 733.212, an interested person who receives a Notice of Administration generally has 3 months from the date of service to contest the will. Missing that deadline can eliminate the right to challenge entirely. Florida Statute 732.901 also requires the custodian of a will to file the original with the Clerk of Court within 10 days of learning of the decedent’s death. Because we regularly work within Florida probate procedures, we track required timelines for will contests, objections to accountings, and petitions to remove a personal representative. We also give you a clear picture of how the local court is likely to manage status conferences, mediation orders, and trial settings, so you can prepare practically and emotionally for each phase of the case.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Probate Litigation?

Probate litigation involves legal disputes over the administration of a deceased person’s estate. These disputes may arise from disagreements over the validity of a will, the distribution of assets, or the conduct of an executor or trustee. In Florida, probate litigation is shaped by specific state statutes governing estates and the rights of heirs, beneficiaries, and personal representatives. We assist clients through these proceedings with clear guidance and representation at every stage.

When Should I Consult a Probate Litigation Attorney?

As early as possible after a dispute arises or a Notice of Administration is received. Early intervention helps you understand your legal rights, the strength of your claims, and potential resolutions before deadlines pass. Under Florida law, the window to contest a will is generally 3 months from the date the Notice of Administration is served, so reaching out quickly protects your ability to act.

How Long Does Probate Litigation Take in Florida?

Duration varies widely based on the complexity of the issues, the number of parties involved, and whether a settlement is reached. Matters can resolve in a few months or extend over several years when they proceed to trial. We work to resolve disputes as efficiently as possible while protecting our clients’ interests at every stage.

What Are Common Reasons for Probate Litigation?

Common causes include contesting a will’s validity due to undue influence, lack of testamentary capacity, or improper execution. Trust administration disputes, fiduciary misconduct, disagreements over document interpretation, and conflicts over asset distribution are also frequent. Elective share and homestead classification disputes are particularly common in Florida given the state’s specific statutes in these areas.

How Much Does Probate Litigation Cost?

Costs vary by case complexity, the time required, and whether a matter goes to trial or settles earlier. We provide clear communication about potential costs and work toward resolutions that make financial sense for our clients, starting with a transparent conversation at the initial consultation so you can make informed decisions throughout the process.

Talk to Our Probate Litigation Team

If you’re facing a probate dispute in Florida, you don’t have to navigate it alone. Our team takes the time to explain what the court is likely to consider, what documentation you may want to gather, and what options you have for resolving conflict before it does lasting damage to family relationships.

Clear explanation of options so you understand the possible paths forward and the trade-offs of each choice.
Guidance on documentation you may want to gather, such as financial records and prior estate planning paperwork.
Regular case updates so you know what has happened, what comes next, and how to prepare.
Thoughtful approach to family dynamics aimed at reducing conflict where possible while still protecting your legal rights.

Many families come to us in the middle of an emotionally charged situation, unsure whether to pursue a claim or how to respond to actions taken by a personal representative or trustee. We give you a clear path forward so you feel supported, not overwhelmed, as your case moves through the Florida probate system.

Contact Dorcey Law Firm, PLC today at (239) 309-2870 for a free initial consultation.

Estate Planning Services We Can Help You With

No matter how complex or contentious your situation is, we will clearly outline your options and develop a thorough strategy for achieving your objectives.

Our Services

All Services

Florida Probate Law: Key Statutes That Drive Disputes

Florida’s probate statutes create specific rights, deadlines, and obligations that directly shape how disputes arise and how they can be resolved. Understanding this statutory framework is essential before deciding how to respond to a contested estate matter.

The Notice of Administration Deadline

When a personal representative opens a Florida probate proceeding, interested parties receive a Notice of Administration. Under Florida Statute 733.212, that notice triggers a 3-month window to file an objection or contest the will. This deadline is strictly enforced, and missing it typically eliminates the right to challenge. If you’ve received a Notice of Administration and have concerns about the estate, contacting an attorney promptly is an important step you can take.

Elective Share Rights in Florida

Florida’s elective share statute entitles a surviving spouse to 30% of the elective estate regardless of what the will provides, unless a valid premarital or postnuptial agreement waives that right. Elective share claims are among the most common sources of probate litigation in Florida because the calculation of the elective estate itself can be disputed, especially when non-probate assets, jointly held accounts, and trust assets are involved. Surviving spouses who believe their statutory rights have been overlooked have remedies available, but those remedies carry their own filing requirements and deadlines.

Homestead Property Disputes

Florida’s homestead laws restrict how a primary residence may be devised when a surviving spouse or minor children survive the decedent. Whether property qualifies as homestead and how it may be transferred are recurring questions in Florida probate courts. Disputes can arise between a surviving spouse and adult children from a prior relationship, between heirs and creditors, or when an estate plan attempted to transfer homestead property in a way Florida law doesn’t permit.

Creditor Claims and Distribution Delays

Creditor claims against a Florida estate must be filed within specific deadlines set by the Florida Probate Code. Disputes over the validity or priority of those claims can delay distribution to beneficiaries and may require court intervention to resolve. Beneficiaries waiting on a distribution while creditor issues remain open benefit from understanding how the process is supposed to work, and whether the personal representative is managing it correctly.

Personal Representative Duties and Removal

Personal representatives in Florida have a legal duty to file an inventory and provide accountings to beneficiaries. When a personal representative fails to meet these obligations, beneficiaries may petition the court to compel compliance or seek removal. Removal actions can also be based on conflicts of interest, preferential treatment of certain heirs, or mismanagement of estate assets. Florida law provides clear remedies in these situations, including surcharge actions that can hold a fiduciary personally responsible for losses caused by misconduct.

Recognizing When a Probate Matter Requires Legal Intervention

Not every difficult estate administration rises to the level of litigation, but some warning signs indicate that legal intervention may be necessary. Identifying these signals early gives you more options and preserves rights that could otherwise lapse.

A personal representative who refuses to communicate with beneficiaries, delays providing an inventory, or fails to respond to requests for information is a significant red flag. Florida law requires transparency in estate administration, and consistent stonewalling often signals a deeper problem. Unexplained changes to a will or trust made shortly before death, particularly when the decedent was elderly or in declining health, can also indicate undue influence or lack of testamentary capacity at the time of signing.

When a caregiver, new romantic partner, or close associate appears to have influenced an elderly decedent to change estate documents in their favor, Florida courts can examine whether those changes reflect the decedent’s genuine intentions or the product of manipulation. Evidence in these cases often includes medical records documenting cognitive decline alongside a timeline of document changes.

When a personal representative has a conflict of interest, is mismanaging assets, or is favoring one beneficiary’s interests over others, Florida law provides remedies including removal, surcharge actions, and appointment of a successor. The sooner these issues are raised with counsel, the more options remain available to you.

The Dorcey Law Direction

High Value Service
We pride ourselves in giving you high-value legal services and results for the money that you pay.
Established Roots in Florida
We have strong roots in Fort Myers and surrounding cities. We are well established and promise to be around to represent you, your children, and grandchildren!
Education is Key!
We host weekly seminars and are dedicated to teaching our clients about the process and legalities surrounding estate planning and probate. Learn more about how you can join our Auto-Pilot program today!
We Are Your Neighbors
We are not the typical attorneys you will find in Florida. We are laid back and down to earth and believe in being someone you can talk with about delicate issues as if we were neighbors.

Allow Us To Be the Guide in Your Journey

First Name
Please enter your first name.
Last Name
Please enter your last name.
Phone
Please enter your phone number.

This isn't a valid phone number.
Email
Please enter your email address.

This isn't a valid email address.
Are you a new client?
Please make a selection.
How can we help you?
Please enter a message.
By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from Dorcey Law Firm, PLC at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy

How Our Estate Planning Background Shapes Our Litigation Approach

Most probate litigation firms work backward through documents they’re seeing for the first time. At Dorcey Law Firm, PLC, our litigation team works within a firm that actively builds, funds, and maintains estate plans for Florida families. That distinction changes how we approach a disputed matter from day one.

Direct Familiarity with Trust Funding and Asset Titling

We assist with hundreds of trust-related matters annually. That volume of direct work with trust funding, asset titling, and beneficiary designations gives our team a working familiarity with how these documents function in practice, not just how they read on paper. When a dispute arises over how an asset was titled or whether a beneficiary designation was updated as intended, we already understand the mechanics of how those steps are supposed to work and where the process commonly breaks down.

Our full-time Trust Funding Department handles the implementation side of estate planning: transferring assets into trusts, coordinating with financial institutions, and tracking whether each component of a plan has been properly completed. For litigation clients, this means we can quickly assess whether an asset was correctly aligned with the estate plan or whether a gap in funding created the dispute now before the court. These are details that might take an outside firm weeks to reconstruct.

Document History and Planning Intent

The Auto-Pilot Planning Program documents ongoing updates to client estate plans. When a dispute involves a recent change to an estate document, such as a new amendment executed shortly before death or a shift in beneficiary designations, the history of how those documents evolved matters. We know how to read that history and how to explain it clearly in negotiations or before a judge.

Long-term client relationships also mean we sometimes have direct knowledge of a family’s planning intentions that an outside firm would need months of discovery to piece together. That context can be decisive in disputes where the central question is what the decedent actually intended and whether the documents in place reflect those intentions. We bring that planning-rooted perspective to every contested matter we handle in Florida, giving clients a faster, clearer path to understanding what happened and what can be done about it.